Structures, Spaces, and Boundary Making. Handbooks continue to abound, at least with Anglo-American publishers, and given the recent hype around world and global history, nothing seems more obvious than the attempt to establish an authoritative survey mapping this dynamic field.
Beck, published since And like the US-German co-production, it instead opts for volumes following a chronological order. This permits the inclusion of a wider range of topics for any given period and easier orientation for the reader.
Volume VII, the focus of this review, consists of two parts with more than 1, pages and 44 contributions including the introduction.
The volume combines essays scrutinizing broad processes for the full period since with pieces on a non-exhaustive list of moments. This list of entries reveals several choices with positive and negative aspects: Firstly, world history is not parceled out along nations, civilizations, or the like, as earlier works frequently did. The chosen approach allows meaningful links to Historische rezensionen online dating revealed and phenomena and processes to be compared as they unfolded across various parts of the world.
One might say that the volume is therefore in line with the new orthodoxy world and global history. However, it also goes beyond this approach in interesting ways. Six of the chapters revisit the place of various macro-regions. Among other things, he shows that Middle Eastern movements were an early sign of the global resurgence of religion, thus challenging dated notions about secularization and the peripheral role of this area.
The other essays in this section also go beyond the essentialist and monadic narratives characteristic of an older literature; having them in the collection makes the volume much richer than it would have been otherwise.
Secondly, and despite its long list of chapters, the Cambridge series does not endeavor to be comprehensive. While some contributions do cover core phenomena and processes, others mainly serve as examples for what world history seeks to accomplish. In general, this approach makes a lot of sense, but some of the concrete choices can easily be challenged.
Why, for instance, highlight world cinema and not the Historische rezensionen online dating of mass media and entertainment more generally, and why do and not or ? Unfortunately, readers learn little about the reasons for these choices beyond the pragmatic criterion of existing research; volume editors John R.
Another problem is closely linked to this: Their choices target particularly the palate of contemporary historians: This — as well as topics such as the automobile and the cinema — gives good parts of the volume a presentistic bent; a trend that is further reinforced by the foci within some of the chapters.
The essays on genocide and music, for instance, confine themselves mostly to the twentieth century. While such a decision might help to convince a skeptical audience that world history matters, it also comes at a price: Besides obvious global moments in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, chapters on topics such as horses, coal, jade Historische rezensionen online dating honor and hierarchy would have helped to correct that.
In this sense, this collection could have gone further in mapping the less explored dimensions of the field and giving world history a less presentistic and possibly even teleological twist. Thirdly, and closely related, on periodization more broadly: While convincing in many other respects, the American-German co-production received criticism for introducing the rather artificial divide of between volumes 5 and 6.
Some of the best contributions to that series simply chose to ignore the ordering principle.
It goes beyond the scope of this review to discuss the periodization of all seven volumes; what can be said, however, is that the choice for the last is "Historische rezensionen online dating" and fully plausible. The editors and many of the authors certainly work hard to overcome Eurocentric notions and interpretations along with diffusionist notions of links between societies — as features that characterized many older works in world history.
The project also combines macro-comparisons and large-scale analyses of political and economic processes with chapters that stress the volatility and fluidity of interactions, and dynamics of cultural translation and representation. However, several chapters remain surprisingly Eurocentric, such as the contribution on sport, not least due to its strong focus on international organizations active in the field, or the essay on world technology.
The volume would probably have done better without them. The regional distribution of authors "Historische rezensionen online dating" also sobering: To be fair, other volumes in this series have a slightly more balanced geographical spread, but modern world history at least continues to be a rather biased affair.
The lack of plurality becomes even more striking if one considers that quite a few of the contributors also played leading roles in some of the other encyclopedia and handbook projects: The field of scholars contributing to the debate — at least this level of the debate — remains conspicuously small.
It will therefore be an indispensable work for years to come. Having said this, it also reminds us that there is still a lot of work to do before world or global history will be worldly and global enough. Copyright c by Clio-online and Arbeitskreis Historische Friedens- und Konfliktforschung, all rights reserved.
Die Rezension ist hervorgegangen aus der Kooperation mit dem Arbeitskreis Historische Friedens- und Konfliktforschung. Jahrhundert,, Rezensiert für den Arbeitskreis Historische Friedens- und.